Publisher’s Platform: A Modest Proposal: The Donald J. Trump Safe Food Act, aka the Make Food Safety Great Again Act

I have a naming problem. Since September I have been circulating a working paper called Project 2027: thirty-five proposals for safer food, sent to well over a hundred individuals and organizations for comment. The tagline is “Known Problems, Known Solutions. Bold but doable.” The proposals have held up well. The name, I will admit, was not my best work. Any project with a year in its title now gets compared to a certain other one.

Here is my fix. Call it the Donald J. Trump Safe Food Act. Also known as the Make Food Safety Great Again Act.

The precedent is there. In this term alone the Trump name has gone onto savings accounts for children, a prescription drug website, a visa, a planned class of Navy battleships, the U.S. Institute of Peace and a four-mile road in Palm Beach County, as the Associated Press has catalogued. There is even a legal roadmap. When the Kennedy Center board added the President’s name to the building, a federal judge ordered it removed in May, reasoning that Congress named the place and “only Congress can change it.” Fair enough. Food safety law is made by Congress. An act passed by both chambers and signed in the Rose Garden would survive any court in the country. I would attend. I would clap.

The President is a well-known germophobe. I mean that as a compliment. In my line of work, it is a qualification and perhaps rare common ground. He once explained his fondness for fast food by saying “I like cleanliness.” I do too. Here is what the Act would do.

Chronic disease comes first, and here is why

I have spent thirty-three years on bacteria and viruses, and a list from me could easily bury chronic disease at the bottom. It goes first because that is where most of the sickness, most of the deaths and most of the money is. Heart disease and stroke killed more than 850,000 Americans in 2024, more than foodborne illness has killed in all the years since Jack in the Box. About ninety cents of every health care dollar goes to chronic and mental health conditions. It may also be the place this administration is most ready to start. The Secretary of Health and Human Services said on camera in February that FDA would act on a petition on ultra-processed food. The two halves of food policy have worked in separate rooms for too long, and neither is winning alone.

1. Define ultra-processed food. About 62 percent of children’s calories come from these foods, and Washington has yet to publish a definition. Adopt a benchmark now that works in a contract and a study, not just a press release.

2. Front-of-package labeling. FDA proposed a front-of-package label for saturated fat, sodium and added sugars in January 2025 and has not finished it. Finalize it in 2027.

3. School food. California passed a definition in 2025 and required ultra-processed foods of concern out of school meals. Carry that template into the 2027 state sessions, and where a ban will not pass, write the standard into the purchasing contract.

What Congress would do in the President’s name

4. Kill the traceability rider. The law that ended the 2025 shutdown bars FDA from spending money to enforce its own food traceability rule before July 20, 2028, and prods the agency to weaken lot-level tracking. No version of that language belongs in the fiscal 2027 spending package.

5. Pass the infant formula bill. Two botulism outbreaks in twelve months put 52 infants in the hospital, and Clostridium botulinum was never on the required testing list. H.R. 7867 expands pathogen testing and requires reporting of positives. FDA can also do it by rule now.

6. Limit heavy metals in baby food. FDA’s lead levels are guidance, which is slow to set and slow to tighten. H.R. 8429 directs FDA to set limits for lead, cadmium, mercury and arsenic by order, with mandatory recall authority for food that exceeds them.

7. Approve food chemicals before they are sold. A company may still put a novel ingredient into food on its own say-so. Roughly four hundred of my clients got sick from tara flour no one had reviewed. Require premarket approval, not premarket paperwork.

8. No federal preemption of state food law. A draft bill in Congress would supersede state rules on additives, allergen disclosure, heavy metal limits and restaurant inspection, in most cases with nothing federal to replace them. Defeat the clause, in any form.

9. Share inspection information both ways. In an outbreak the states know first, and the federal count lags by weeks. H.R. 8430 moves information between FDA and the states. States should also send FDA the results of the produce farm inspections FDA pays for.

10. Protect whistleblowers on the line. The food safety whistleblower law covers FDA-regulated facilities, not most meat and poultry plants. Give a plant worker or contract grower who reports adulterated product the same protection as a warehouse worker who reports a rodent.

11. Close the sesame loophole. Adding sesame to a product for no purpose except to avoid cleaning a production line is a failure of good manufacturing practice, and FDA can say so today. If it will not, Congress should amend the statute.

12. Let FDA sample next to the field. In the 2018 Yuma romaine outbreak the strain was found in canal water running past a large cattle feeding operation, and FDA had no authority to sample there. S. 376 and H.R. 852 would give it access during an outbreak investigation.

13. Send an inspector when an outbreak points at a plant. In September FDA listed seventeen open outbreak investigations, most with no on-site inspection. Require a for-cause inspection within a set period once an outbreak is linked to a firm, with the findings made public.

14. An inspection floor for the foods that keep making people sick. Leafy greens, sprouts, cantaloupe, frozen berries, onions, cucumbers and shell eggs cause repeated outbreaks, yet a facility handling them can go three to five years between visits. Congress already requires annual inspection of infant formula plants. Extend the model.

What the agencies would do with authority they already have with a nudge from the President

15. Salmonella in poultry. Salmonella is an adulterant in exactly one raw poultry product, breaded stuffed chicken, and USDA has stopped testing for it. Enforce that standard, then broaden it to the strains that cause outbreaks.

16. Line speeds. A proposed rule would take chicken lines from 140 to 175 birds a minute and drop the annual worker safety attestation. Do not finalize it as written. Any plant running above 140 should carry a staffing condition, and the attestation should stay.

17. Finish the food chemical rule. FDA’s proposal makes notification of “generally recognized as safe” ingredients mandatory, but a company may still ship first. Require notice before sale, publish the firms that do not comply and charge a fee to pay for the review.

18. Restore surveillance. In July 2025 FoodNet went from tracking eight pathogens to two. Protect the public health laboratories that do the sequencing behind every multistate outbreak, then restore all eight. Every other number depends on them.

19. Publish the testing we already pay for. From 2001 to 2012 a USDA program tested more than 111,000 samples of fresh produce for about $4.5 million a year, and between 2009 and 2012 it triggered 38 recalls. Bring it back and publish the state testing FDA already funds.

20. Count what happens afterward. Nobody tracks the child who leaves the hospital with a damaged kidney. Build a national registry of the long-term outcomes of foodborne illness, so the cost of an outbreak is more than the number of people sick that week.

21. Answer the petitions. Citizen petitions on antibiotics, lead in baby food and ultra-processed food sit unanswered at FDA. Answer all of them in 2027 and give the agency the staff to do it. A denial with reasons is more useful than another year of silence.

22. Name the companies. FDA will not name a company linked to an outbreak unless there is a recall. The 2024 romaine outbreak sickened 89 people and killed one, and the public was never told whose lettuce it was. A company’s name is not a trade secret.

23. Publish the store list with the recall. Lists of where recalled food was sold surface weeks late, in a database nothing indexes. Publish them when the recall is announced, on the model USDA adopted in 2008, and keep the outbreak investigations table current.

24. Criminal enforcement. The Justice Department eliminated its Consumer Protection Branch in September 2025. Publish charging guidelines for food cases, and say plainly whether the strict-liability misdemeanor is still charged.

25. Imported food. This summer’s lettuce came from Mexico and the frozen blueberries from Chile. Publish the foreign inspection, supplier verification and import alert numbers every year, fund the inspections and stop counting a remote records review as an inspection.

26. A national strategy. Food safety has been on GAO’s High-Risk List since 2007, and GAO asked for a government-wide strategy in 2017. Fifteen agencies, thirty statutes, no plan. Write one. It takes no legislation.

27. A warning label on raw sprouts. For twenty-eight years FDA has told children, older adults, pregnant women and people with weakened immune systems not to eat raw sprouts, and never once on the package. Put it there.

28. Raw milk cheese. FDA said in 2013 it would reevaluate the 60-day aging rule and has not. Four outbreaks in thirty-one months came from cheese that complied with it. Finish the review and put a warning on the label.

29. Antibiotics. Sales of medically important antibiotics for food animals reached nearly 7.1 million kilograms in 2024, up 16 percent in a year, most of it given to whole herds and flocks in feed or water. Grant the petition sixty-five organizations filed in June.

What the states would do with the President’s encouragement

30. Finish the state baby food laws. A handful of states require testing baby food for heavy metals and posting the results. Six states should become twelve, and the next bills should add pathogen testing of powdered formula.

31. Use the Food Code. Restaurants and retail generate most of the outbreaks people actually experience, and the Food Code governs them. Take issues to the Conference for Food Protection for its April 2027 meeting.

32. Norovirus. Norovirus causes 5.5 million foodborne illnesses a year, more than any other pathogen, most often through a food worker who came in sick because staying home cost a shift. Enforce the illness exclusion and pass paid sick leave.

33. Defend state authority and use it. States conduct more than a million food inspections a year. Make preemption a political cost for any member who supports it, and finish the state business on farm water, hepatitis A vaccination for food workers and raw milk.

What industry would do at the signing ceremony in the new ball room

34. Build to lot codes anyway. The rider froze the traceability rule, and some firms took that as permission to stop building. Three of the largest grocers did not. Keep building and publish a list of the companies that have committed.

35. Buy safety. Large buyers have more leverage over a supplier than any inspector does. Write food safety into purchase orders, audit against them and publish what the audits find.

The serious part

Theodore Roosevelt signed the Pure Food and Drug Act and the Meat Inspection Act on the same day in 1906. Neither carries his name. His reputation survived. Barack Obama signed the Food Safety Modernization Act in 2011 (a copy hangs on my office wall). I am telling you I would happily see another President’s name on the next one.

Project 2027 is not about me, and it is not about who gets credit. It is about preventing the next Kevin Kowalcyk or Riley Detwiler, two little boys who died from hamburger that should never have been sold. E. colidoes not check voter registration. Neither do Salmonella, Listeria or Cyclospora. Our voices are stronger together than separate, and that sentence has no party attached to it.

Mr. President, the name is yours if you want it. All I ask is that the thirty-five things come with it. If you pass, I will keep the boring name, and the offer stays open to anyone in either party holding a pen.

Anyone who wants to read the working paper and tell me what I got wrong can email me at [email protected].

Share:

More Posts

Send Us A Message



Scroll to Top