Publisher’s Platform: Why MAHA Lost, and How It Gets Its MOJO Back

Two weeks ago, the Make America Healthy Again movement had its first real test at the ballot box, and it failed. Political scientists Robert Brehm and Matt Motta, writing in The Conversation, count more than half of the 24 candidates endorsed by MAHA Action among the losers. STAT counted at least eleven MAHA-aligned defeats, including Senator Roger Marshall of Kansas, a founder of the MAHA Caucus. In Iowa, Zach Lahn, the candidate the movement held up as its model, lost the governor’s race to Democrat Rob Sand by double digits after MAHA-aligned groups put more than $1.5 million behind him. On January 3, Democrats take both chambers of Congress.

I have spent thirty-three years representing people poisoned by their food, and I have agreed with a good deal of what MAHA says about what is on the American plate. That is why the loss is worth understanding.

The short answer. MAHA did not lose because Americans stopped caring what is in their food. It lost because it asked the right questions and then accepted the wrong answers: a federal food safety system that got weaker on its watch, promises on food chemicals that were not kept, and a fight with vaccine science that most of its own voters never asked for. It gets its MOJO back by dropping the anti-science and finishing the food agenda.

Were MAHA’s ideas unpopular? No.

KFF’s polling this spring found about four in ten adults supporting the movement. More to the point, 75 percent of the public said there is not enough regulation of chemical additives in food, and 64 percent said the same about agricultural pesticides. Those are not partisan numbers.

The same poll explains part of the loss. Asked for their top health priority, 42 percent of MAHA-supporting voters picked lowering health care costs. Restricting food additives drew 21 percent. Reevaluating vaccine safety drew 10 percent. The issue the movement’s leaders talk about most is the one its voters care about least. And some of November was simply the tide; Brehm and Motta are right that a national swing of that size sinks candidates of every kind.

What did MAHA voters actually get?

Here is the record, all of it from the government’s own actions. In 2025 the federal government cut its active foodborne illness surveillance network, FoodNet, from eight pathogens to two. It withdrew a poultry Salmonella standard three years in the making. It froze its own food traceability rule through an appropriations rider. It eliminated the Justice Department branch that prosecuted food cases.

Then came 2026 and the largest Cyclospora season in American history: 20,996 laboratory-confirmed cases by CDC’s count as of October 23, with 12,883 of them in a single outbreak traced to iceberg lettuce. That arrived one year after the surveillance network dropped the parasite from its list.

On chemicals, the signature issue, FDA’s August proposal on “generally recognized as safe” ingredients requires companies to notify the agency. Notification is not approval. Former FDA Commissioner David Kessler’s petition on ultra-processed food has been pending since August 2025; the Secretary said on camera in February that the agency would act, and it has not. The front-of-package nutrition label proposed in January 2025 is still not final.

MAHA’s own people noticed. STAT reports a movement scorecard that found the administration partly kept five promises and broke 37. Senator Ron Johnson, a Republican, said last week that the administration had not delivered for MAHA and that it showed in the results.

What did the anti-science cost?

CDC had confirmed 5,412 measles cases this year as of November 12, more than double the 2,289 of 2025 and the most since 1991. State health departments have reported ten deaths. KFF Health News reported Saturday that the Pan American Health Organization has concluded the United States no longer qualifies as a country that has eliminated measles, a status held since 2000. CDC’s data show 96 percent of this year’s cases in people who were unvaccinated or whose status was unknown. Mr. Lahn, the model candidate, promised to ban COVID-19 vaccination in Iowa.

In my own practice the same thing shows up as raw milk. Sales keep expanding in state after state, and the children who end up on dialysis with E. coli infections keep ending up in my office.

A movement cannot tell parents it will protect their children from food dyes and then shrug at measles and at unpasteurized milk. The science that says lead does not belong in baby food is the same science that says vaccines work and pasteurization works. Nobody gets to keep the half they like. Every hour spent relitigating the childhood vaccine schedule is an hour not spent on additives, pesticides, heavy metals and ultra-processed food, which is where the 75 percent are.

How does MAHA get its MOJO back?

Give up the anti-science, and pick up a list. I have been circulating one. Project 2027 is a working paper, now in the hands of well over a hundred people and organizations, with thirty-five specific things that would make American food safer and can be done within a year. Much of it is exactly what MAHA’s voters said they wanted:

Food chemicals. Premarket approval, not premarket paperwork. Two bills heard in April, H.R. 4958 and H.R. 4306, do that work.

Baby food. Pass H.R. 8429, so FDA sets limits for lead, cadmium, mercury and arsenic by order.

Infant formula. Fifty-two infants were sickened with botulism in two outbreaks traced to one supply of milk powder. The Senate passed S. 272 without objection in April. It has sat at the Speaker’s desk since May.

Ultra-processed food. Answer the Kessler petition. Finalize the front-of-package label. Publish a definition that can be used in a contract, not just a press release.

Antibiotics. Grant the June 2026 petition from sixty-five organizations to end routine use of medically important antibiotics in animals that are not sick.

The states. No federal preemption of state food law. The states are where MAHA has actually won, and the preemption clause now in circulation would erase those wins.

The basics. Restore FoodNet to eight pathogens, keep the traceability rule, and name the companies linked to outbreaks.

None of that requires anyone to doubt a vaccine. All of it requires believing the laboratory.

Who picks up the agenda if MAHA does not?

Somebody already has. On September 1 a House Democratic working group sent its leadership an eighty-four-page plan for the new Congress. Its food section is built on the position that the concerns MAHA raised are legitimate and overdue for a legislative answer, and STAT reports the section is titled “Reclaiming MAHA.” Three of the bills above are on its first-100-hours and first-100-days lists.

That is fine by me. Safe food has never belonged to a party. But it should tell the movement something: its issues are winning while its candidates lose. What separates the two is credibility.

I will work with anyone on these thirty-five items, Republican, Democrat or MAHA mom. And the offer I made to the Secretary in writing on June 25 still stands: sit for an hour, in private, with a family whose child was poisoned by food. Then let’s finish the list.

Share:

More Posts

The ‘Lo Mein Loophole’

This article was produced in collaboration with Virginia Quarterly Review. It may not be reproduced without express permission from FERN.

Send Us A Message



Scroll to Top